Elyssa is a full-time Real Estate Broker serving the Indianapolis metropolitan area, known for her expertise in time-sensitive research, data analysis, strategic problem-solving, and skilled negotiation. With a client-focused mindset, she delivers a highly personalized experience, ensuring that each buyer and seller receives attentive, honest, and responsive service throughout the entire process. Elyssa is passionate about building lasting relationships and takes pride in guiding her clients with clarity and confidence through every step of their real estate journey. She looks forward to helping you achieve your real estate goals with professionalism and care.
Property Spotlight
Explore the City. Find Your Place.
Greenwood
Description/informational text goes here with editable font sizing for legibility.
Bargersville
Description/informational text goes here with editable font sizing for legibility.
Brownburg
Description/informational text goes here with editable font sizing for legibility.
Plainfield
Description/informational text goes here with editable font sizing for legibility.
Noblesville
Description/informational text goes here with editable font sizing for legibility.
Westfield
Description/informational text goes here with editable font sizing for legibility.
Stay in the Know with Neighborhood News
Get free monthly updates on the housing market in your area—delivered straight to your inbox. From home values to market trends, Neighborhood News keeps you informed so you can make confident real estate decisions.
Client Chatter
My Recent Testimonials
-
“As a first time home buyer, Elyssa made the experience enjoyable and less stressful! She was available at any time to answer any questions we had, whether it be a phone call or text away. If we wanted to view a property, Elyssa was on it right away to see if we could get in to view the property asap. She paid great attention to our needs and wants and was very honest when noting if she thought a house would be a great fit for us or not. She was always professional and on time to our viewings and meetings. Elyssa was an excellent negotiater and made sure to always read and explain documents to or from the seller. I would recommend Elyssa to anyone who is buying or selling a house. She worked closely with our lender as well, which made the process less stressful as they both answered any questions we had. She is awesome!”
-
“She's the best! Always available when we had questions or concerns. She was honest & patient with us. Once we found our home she was very firm with negotiations and getting us set up for the future. I couldn't recommend her services enough!”
-
“Elyssa Monaghan's efficiency and competency for all-things real estate allowed us to successfully navigate a vast and at times competitive Indianapolis market. She was always thorough and positive, with perfect guidance for a first-time home buyer. Highly recommend.”
-
“Elyssa was not only understanding of all of our needs for housing. But she created us a seamlessly simple process to follow, a quick result for finding and looking at houses. She quickly communicated any and all needs from us to get the process done. She created a perfect experience for me and my wife. I would recommend anyone to Elyssa.”
-
“Elyssa went above and beyond during our home-buying process. She was always available to answer any questions and was able to facilitate meetings with all the people involved when purchasing a new home. This is the second time using Elyssa and could not be more satisfied with how our entire process went from the realtor side of things. We trusted her fully throughout the process and she never let us down. We are sincerely grateful to have used her as a realtor and will continue to recommend her to friends and family.”
-
“Working with Elyssa Monaghan as our realtor was the best decision we made when looking to buy a house. She was super responsive and always answered our questions in a clear way. Even though the market has been very competitive, Elyssa went above and beyond to find us homes to look at and set up tours. She could quickly and efficiently put together contracts so we could submit offers before some crazy deadlines. I never doubted that she had our best interests in mind when she would make recommendations, or give us feedback on a particular home or part of the contracts. Even after we had an accepted offer, she was still heavily involved in helping us find a lender, schedule inspections, and other miscellaneous items as they came up. Elyssa took what could have been an extremely stressful process and made it as simple and seamless as possible. We will recommend her to anyone we know looking for a realtor, and will work with her again when the time comes.”
-
“Elyssa was great to work with. She helped us when we purchased our current home, and helped us when we sold this one. She was easy to communicate with, friendly, professional, and I would recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell their home.”
-
“Elyssa and her team were excellent throughout the entire process! The communication was great, and she was very accessible. As a first-time homebuyer, she made sure I was well informed about the entire process. I would definitely recommend her and her team for anyone looking to buy or sell a house.”
-
“She did well and I have no complaints with her service.”
-
“Elyssa did a great job and really addressed our needs and went the extra mile to find the right property. Great job!”
-
“Elyssa Monaghan did a fantastic job with selling my house. It was sold within 2 weeks! Elyssa’s energy and experience made all of the difference. I would highly recommend her and would definitely use her again myself!”
-
“Elyssa was outstanding in her performance and knowledge. We could not have asked for better than Elyssa.. she was exactly perfectly for us and we deeply appreciate her skillset and work ethic, incredibly satisfied with her !!”
-
“Elyssa Monaghan is able to maintain an incredible level of professionalism while also being someone that one could relax and talk to. Before reaching out to Elyssa, I had no idea what to expect, especially during a quick moving housing market. After speaking with and meeting with her, I knew instantly that I was in good hands and allowed her to do her job. Elyssa Monaghan is highly qualified and I would gladly recommend her services to anyone that I know that is in the market.”
-
“Above and beyond in this crazy market and we appreciate all of the hard work and long hours talking to us. We couldn’t be happier! Thanks Elyssa Monaghan!”
-
“Moving is such a significant change and Elyssa was perfect to work with throughout the whole process! From recommending areas and homes to consider to suggesting competitive offers, Elyssa’s attention to detail, enthusiasm, sincere concern, and professionalism made the process very smooth and efficient. Five stars + to Elyssa! Thanks for a GREAT experience and a GREAT home Elyssa...we love it!”
-
“Elyssa was very easy to get ahold of and moved her schedule around numerous times to make sure we were able to meet with her/see the home etc, whenever was convenient for us, and seemed to be available by text/phone at all hours of the day including weekends. We wanted to move in to a specific area near the country club, so Elyssa took it upon herself to go to the pro shop at the club and ask if anyone knew of anyone in the area that was looking to sell, which we thought was a great idea and more than just the standard level of service provided by some realtors. She was able to get us into the home we ended up buying on the morning that it went on the market, which was great. Elyssa helped us sell our home as well. We received a full asking price offer, as is, out of the gate.. There were a number of hiccups along the way but Elyssa kept us fully informed and helped us through some tough decisions. She even stopped by the home we were selling to check on some work that was being done when my wife and I were out of the country on vacation. Overall, we are very happy with the services Elyssa provided throughout the purchase of our new home and the sale of our previous home!”
-
“Elyssa Monaghan was extremely professional and kept me informed throughout the process. I would definitely recommend her to any family or friends!”
-
“Great experience with Elyssa. Her communication skills were excellent and the transaction went very smooth. I would not hesitate to use her again”
1. Source: Insert the source for your Accolades or Claim. 2. Source: Insert the source for your Accolade or Claim.
© 2024 Century 21 Real Estate LLC used under license by CENTURY 21 affiliated franchise. All rights reserved. CENTURY 21®, C21® and the CENTURY 21 Logo are service marks owned by Century 21 Real Estate LLC. CENTURY 21 affiliated franchisee fully supports the principles of the Fair Housing Act and the Equal Opportunity Act. Each office is independently owned and operated. If you become an independent sales associate affiliated with a CENTURY 21 franchised office, you have a variety of resources, tools, technologies and educational opportunities available to you, including programs and materials. Use of any such materials and any related programs are not mandatory but instead are completely voluntary for you to use at your discretion if they fit your business needs. No tool or program described in herein is intended to imply or create an employment relationship with any CENTURY 21 franchisee or with Century 21 Real Estate LLC.
© 2025 MoxiWorks
© CENTURY 21 2023 - 2024. All rights reserved. CENTURY 21®, C21® and the CENTURY 21 Logo are registered service marks owned by Century 21 Real Estate LLC. Franchisee Legal Entity Name (not the dba) fully supports the principles of the Fair Housing Act and the Equal Opportunity Act. Each franchise is independently owned and operated. Any services or products provided by independently owned and operated franchisees are not provided by, affiliated with, or related to Century 21 Real Estate LLC nor any of its affiliated companies.
